CSIR-NET
46.
Youngs modulus of a rock specimen of density 2.7 gm/cc is 9.72
megabar. The longitudinal wave velocity (in km/s) in the rock is
1.
4.8
2.
5.2
3.
6.0
4.
7.2
Solution:
Using Young's modulus we can calculate the Bulk modulus and rigidity modulus and then finally we can calculate the P-wave velocity (Please check it comment section). In this case I'm not getting the answer.
If I calculate the One-dimensional Wave velocity,
Wave Velocity (V) = √(E/ ρ) -------------------(1)
E-Young's modulus = 9.72 megabar
=
9.72 *106 bar
=9.72*
1011 pascal
=972*
109 pascal
Density
= 2.7 gm/cc
=2700
kg/m3
Above
valuses substitute in eq(1)
V = √ (972*109 /2700)
V = √ (36*107)
V=6000
m/s
V = 6 km/s
(
I am getting one zero extra. If anyone knows please correct this
problem)
Another solution:
Thanks to Rohit Jha,
Using Inverse Gardner equation from density
in $\rho$ gm/cc and velocity of the longitudinal wave is in m/s
Given values,
$\rho$=2.7 gm/cc
What is $V_p$ is in m/s?
$V_p=108 \rho^4$
$V_p=108 (2.7)^4$
$V_p=5739.56 m/s$
Therefore $V_p=5.739 km/s$
Reference :Gardner's equation - SubSurfWiki
Same problem :(
ReplyDeleteSuper Brother. You are doing Good Job really, Keep it up.
ReplyDeleteThank you brother...
DeleteGiven youngs modulus not bulk .. still nice work keep it up .
ReplyDeleteIt's given young's modulus not bulk modulus sir.By putting Young's modulus formula it's not giving any of the given value. Please help me out for this. Thank you
ReplyDeletevery nice doubt subh..
Deleteuse K= E/3(1-2v),
DeleteK bulk modulus
E young's modulus
v poisson's ratio (0.25 for ideal case)
for this values
k= 648*10^9
submit this value in Vp^2= (k/p)
p- density
Answer for this: 4.8 km/s (please check it once)
Thank you subh...
Deleteno answer is 6.0
DeleteIf you like this blog, please follow me.. Please share your solution..
DeleteVery good job. Thank you for solution.
ReplyDeleteBut
VP = √ (36*107)
VP=6000 m/s.... How is it come.
VP = √ (36*107) = 6000*√ (10).......Please check it.
Please check above comment which I was posted , in this first we have to calculate bulk modulus using Young's modulus, then we will calculate the longitudinal velocity ...
DeleteFirst we need to calculate bulk modulus using young's modulus, then we need to calculate shear modulus using bulk modulus, then substitute in the Vp formula and the answer will come 20.7 km/sec....need to change bar into pascal and gm/cc into kg/m3
ReplyDeleteok i will check it...
DeleteBut one more thing we have to consider, no where in the earth the the P-wave velocity is 20km/s.
DeleteSir, what he said is correct. We have to solve it like that. But i am getting 2.0 km/sec
Deletewhy havent you considered the rigidity modulus here
ReplyDeleteUse Gardner equation
ReplyDeleteVp= 108*(density)^4 m/sec
Vp= 108*(2.7)^4
Vp= 5739.36 m/s
Vp= 5.739 km/s
Vp=6km/s(Approx)
Thank you Rohit. Please send me name of the reference text book.
Deletehttps://www.subsurfwiki.org/wiki/Gardner%27s_equation#:~:text=Gardner's%20equation%20is%20an%20empirical,when%20performing%20a%20well%20tie).
ReplyDeleteThank you so much Rohit. So In this case we won't consider the Young's modulus right. I will update your solution also.
Delete